Inclusivity and its Limits


Earlier this summer, a series of Salty adverts on Instagram featuring fully clothed BIPOC (Black/Indigenous/People of Color), disabled, plus-sized, and trans women were rejected by the social media mogul for “promoting escorting services.”
 
Something that did not sit well with the editorial team of Salty, a New York-based independent media. “There are rumors, talks, conversations happening in our communities about how certain bodies and perspectives are being policed, and how certain people are targeted for censorship more than others on Instagram,” read the official statements on Salty.
 
The Salty team eventually decided to dig deeper and analyze algorithmic bias in content policing of marginalized communities – a full-fledged report on the matter has just been released by Salty on its website. The membership-driven digital newsletter and platform – committed to amplifying the voices and visibility of women, trans, and nonbinary people – is currently run by 40 volunteers, all of whom speak together through a common voice.
 
The report reveals a multitude of appalling issues, such as that queer people and women of color are policed at a higher rate than the general users on Instagram, and that plus-sized and body-positive profiles were often wrongly flagged for “sexual solicitation” or “excessive nudity.” More importantly, policies that are meant to protect users from racist or sexist behavior on Instagram were instead reported to harm the very groups that need protection.
 
According to the majority of the survey respondents, they were given no reason for actions against their account and were simply told they violated “community guidelines.” “They stated ‘I violated community guidelines',” explained one anonymous survey respondent. “When I inquired how, I was met with silence. I believe I was unfairly targeted by fatphobic bigots who reported my profile and IG did nothing to stop it, instead choosing to delete my account, the person who was harassed.”
 
Following Salty's protest and call-out for “false flags” on Instagram, Facebook Policy officials reached out to rectify the situation and reinstate the ads. According to Salty, they also agreed to meet with the media's team to discuss ways to make the policies more inclusive; however, the empowering discussion around Instagram policies that was supposed to happen never took place as the officials did not follow up the initial conversation.
 
“We fight for visibility every day, and increasingly we find that the perspectives of those we amplify are being silenced – by conscious or unconscious bias built into the framework of our digital world,” Salty's team stated, adding that they are currently working on a more elaborated, 2.0 version of the report, and inviting people to speak out and participate in their on-going survey. “Risqué content featuring thin, cis white women seems less censored than content featuring plus-sized, black, queer women – and cis white men appear to have a free pass to behave and post in any way they please, regardless of the harm they inflict,” the team concluded.
 
Instagram/Facebook Policy officials have yet to officially react to this report and its claims. Since Instagram was bought by Facebook in 2012, the social network has been repeatedly subjected to criticism for its opaque approach to decision making related to community guidelines and borderline content policy. In addition, Facebook is currently under fire for its controversial commitment to political advertising. 


SHARE
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
SIMILAR ARTICLES
Why Nike Won Chinese New Year
By Jing Zhang
For fashion brands, Chinese New Year can be a lucrative period; it is considered a lucky time for...
By Jing Zhang
For fashion brands, Chinese New Year can be a lucrative period; it is considered a lucky time for the Chinese to buy new clothing. The likes of Burberry and Marni regularly release capsules celebrating the new cycle of the Chinese zodiac. Red coloured fashions and accessories (the colour beckons...
For fashion brands, Chinese New Year can be a lucrative period; it is considered a lucky time for the Chinese to buy new clothing. The likes of Burberry and Marni regularly release capsules celebrating the new cycle of the Chinese zodiac. Red coloured fashions and accessories (the colour beckons luck) are everywhere in luxury stores and street markets, as are cute animations of the animal we’re...
Alessandra Facchinetti Joins Harlan+Holden
By Alice Ierace
As it embarks on its fifth year, further expansion within its three markets and a conscious...
By Alice Ierace
As it embarks on its fifth year, further expansion within its three markets and a conscious outlook on online, Seoul-based clothing brand harlan + holden has appointed Alessandra Facchinetti as its first Creative Director.“We are very pleased to announce Alessandra Facchinetti as Creative...
As it embarks on its fifth year, further expansion within its three markets and a conscious outlook on online, Seoul-based clothing brand harlan + holden has appointed Alessandra Facchinetti as its first Creative Director.“We are very pleased to announce Alessandra Facchinetti as Creative Director of harlan + holden. Beyond her immense talent, creativity and experience, we found a partner and...
Matteo De Rosa Joins Dries Van Noten
By Alice Ierace
As one of Puig’s first moves since the acquisition of a majority stake of Dries Van Noten back in...
By Alice Ierace
As one of Puig’s first moves since the acquisition of a majority stake of Dries Van Noten back in 2018, the Spanish company appointed Italian Matteo De Rosa as the fashion brand’s latest President, effective February 1st.De Rosa brings a wealth of experience to the role, which includes six years...
As one of Puig’s first moves since the acquisition of a majority stake of Dries Van Noten back in 2018, the Spanish company appointed Italian Matteo De Rosa as the fashion brand’s latest President, effective February 1st.De Rosa brings a wealth of experience to the role, which includes six years at renowned global retailer Ports 1961 (where he also held the title of Managing Director during his...
Hyerès’ Fashion Finalists: Beyond Traditional Beauty
By Rebecca Voight
France’s upcoming Hyères International Fashion, Photography and Accessories Festival  (April...
By Rebecca Voight
France’s upcoming Hyères International Fashion, Photography and Accessories Festival  (April 23-27) turns thirty-five this year. Like the stylish world it celebrates, the finalists are making their mark with diversity, original materials, artisanal expertise and personal vision. Half of the...
France’s upcoming Hyères International Fashion, Photography and Accessories Festival  (April 23-27) turns thirty-five this year. Like the stylish world it celebrates, the finalists are making their mark with diversity, original materials, artisanal expertise and personal vision. Half of the shortlisted designers, five out of ten, are from France, which shows a marked increase. The rest,...
Mikimoto and Comme des Garçons Unveil Fine Jewellery Collaboration
For the first time in Comme des Garçons' history, fashion designer Rei Kawakubo – the mastermind...
For the first time in Comme des Garçons' history, fashion designer Rei Kawakubo – the mastermind behind both the label and Dover Street Market concept stores – has created a fine jewellery capsule collection using Mikimoto pearls.The collection represents the first stage of a two-year partnership...
For the first time in Comme des Garçons' history, fashion designer Rei Kawakubo – the mastermind behind both the label and Dover Street Market concept stores – has created a fine jewellery capsule collection using Mikimoto pearls.The collection represents the first stage of a two-year partnership between the two brands and aims at blending Kawakubo’s avant-garde approach with the heritage of...
Jean-Paul Gaultier's Last Show
By Gianluca Cantaro
L'Enfant Terrible de la mode never stops to surprise. He dropped the bomb announcing over social...
By Gianluca Cantaro
By Gianluca Cantaro
L'Enfant Terrible de la mode never stops to surprise. He dropped the bomb announcing over social media that this 50th anniversary Haute Couture show would've been the last, shaking up the whole fashion system. Then, continuing with his subtle approach, he started the celebration with the (fake)...
L'Enfant Terrible de la mode never stops to surprise. He dropped the bomb announcing over social media that this 50th anniversary Haute Couture show would've been the last, shaking up the whole fashion system. Then, continuing with his subtle approach, he started the celebration with the (fake) funeral scene from William Klein's 1966 movie "Who Are You, Polly Maggoo?." Lights down, curtain up...
Jean-Pierre Blanc's Unfailing Support for Creation
By Frédéric Martin-Bernard
In 1986, a then young Jean-Pierre Blanc imagined the Hyères Festival while studying. Thirty-five...
By Frédéric Martin-Bernard
In 1986, a then young Jean-Pierre Blanc imagined the Hyères Festival while studying. Thirty-five editions later, the fashion design and photography event which traditionally takes place on the French Riviera can be considered one of the fashion industry's leading events for the discovery of...
In 1986, a then young Jean-Pierre Blanc imagined the Hyères Festival while studying. Thirty-five editions later, the fashion design and photography event which traditionally takes place on the French Riviera can be considered one of the fashion industry's leading events for the discovery of up-and-coming talents. This year, the Festival will take place from April 23rd to 27th. Jonathan Anderson...
High Jewelry's Promising Prospects
By Elisabeta Tudor
Once reserved exclusively for an aristocratic and noble elite, jewellery has become increasingly...
By Elisabeta Tudor
Once reserved exclusively for an aristocratic and noble elite, jewellery has become increasingly democratic since the early 1990s. Many high jewellery brands such as Cartier, Tiffany & Co, Bulgari, and Boucheron have all experienced unprecedented growth during this period and inspired several...
Once reserved exclusively for an aristocratic and noble elite, jewellery has become increasingly democratic since the early 1990s. Many high jewellery brands such as Cartier, Tiffany & Co, Bulgari, and Boucheron have all experienced unprecedented growth during this period and inspired several iconic luxury Maisons — namely Chanel, Louis Vuitton, Dior, Gucci, and Giorgio Armani — to develop...